US Presidential elections – update and forecast

Its nearly that time of the four year presidential cycle again! The polls are close, very close in some of the swing states and tensions are high as America gears up to choose their next president next week.

So where are we on the state of play? Early voting has overall been positive for Republicans, and in particular in Nevada where its looking increasingly likely that Trump will win that state. The so-called Sunbelt states in general are looking promising for the Republicans, including Arizona, Georgia and North Carolina.

Where things are looking far more difficult to predict is the so-called Rust Belt states; Wisconsin (WI), Michigan (MI) and Pennsylvania (PA). In the public polls, Trump has a narrow lead in PA but its effectively a tie in the other two states. I screen my polling to those pollsters who had the best success in 2020 and the overall map they are showing is the following:

As you can see, the overall picture seems to be a likely Trump win but PA is the key state. There are tentative signs that after sliding slowly over the last week or so, the Harris campaign has stabilised and could prevail in at least WI and MI.

One thing is for certain, WI and MI will be extremely close, with PA only a bit closer to the Trump side of things.

My own view is that either side can win this election but I would be surprised but not shocked if Harris pulls of a victory. However, my base case – with around 60% confidence – is Trump will win with 287 plus EC votes and quite possibly a win in the popular vote.

Historically the Rust Belt states vote together so history would suggest Trump should win all three states taking his EC lead to 312. It is simply too hard to say whether this happens this time or not though.

There is also the risk, certainly backed by the recent polling in places like New Hampshire or Virginia, that the Republicans might be able to flip one or more states, on a particularly good night, on top of the Rust Belt. We simply don’t know.

And on that note, enjoy election night!

US Presidential elections – update and forecast

US elections 2024

NBC news

So, we have the US presidential elections coming in November 2024. Now, I’m a US politics geek but even I am struggling to get even remotely excited or even interested by the prospect of these two elderly men fighting it out, again for the role of Commander in Chief.

And I’m not even American.

Polls show that around 6 in 10 Americans do not want a Trump versus Biden repeat.

The third party alternative, No Labels, have published a great memo called “House of Cards” which outline just how unpopular both sides are to so many of the American people. It is worth reading in full which you can do here.

No Labels

As you can see, there is a theoretical path for a third party party to come through this election. And there is signs of a growing backlash against the two legacy parties, note how the most recent meta polling shows a surge in interest in “Others”.

Reviewing the mainstream media, the overwhelming consensus is that most voters will end up voting for whatever is their “lesser evil” candidate, whether Trump or Biden – assuming that Trump wins the primaries which looks very likely – and given how tight the race is, it could go either way.

This post isn’t a forecast – because I simply don’t have a high conviction on this – but I do have a nagging wonder, what if, a third party can build momentum in 2024, and start attracting polling numbers above 15% or so.

In that scenario, with the two lead candidates both sinking in the polls and say No Labels enjoying a huge surge in the polls after their April Convention, maybe we could see a third party force seriously threaten both the Democrats and Republicans in November?

I don’t know. But it is something I will be monitoring closely this year. As my American cousin said to me the other day, “That about sums it up for me. There’s got to be SOMEBODY better than the current 2 bad choices.”

What do you all think? Would love to hear the feedback.

p.s. I don’t recommend political betting (and in some places like America it is illegal) but where I live there are no restrictions. I placed a 400 to 1 bet Joe Manchin will become the next president. Yep, wild and highly unlikely, but, he is a plausible candidate for No Labels and the underlying polling does suggest there is an opportunity for a centrist third party candidate who appeals to both sides, to come through (thanks to AI can already visualise the future! :)).

We’ll see.

US elections 2024